Open letter to Laurie Penny – we love you
Dear Laurie,
You’ve had to deal with a lot of shit of late.
Much of this has come from from people on the right. We hear tales of threats of rape and of violence on right wing blogs and on police forums.
Such people are just malicious arseholes. It would be nice if we could all ignore them. But sometimes, it’s hard to ignore it when people threaten you with physical violence, or with rape. It’s scary. No one should have to deal with that shit.
Sometimes such people are called trolls. But this somewhat comic monkier doesn’t seem appropriate once they start threatening you. So, here’s what we say to these vindictive arseholes:
What is it about abusing people that gets you so aroused? Is it that you are so pathetic, so weak, and so inarticulate that this is the only way you can express yourself? Maybe it’s only when you are sitting in a darkened room writing about how violent you’d like to be that you truly feel human? If so, you need help. Go get some counselling. Or maybe just get drunk, or take some drugs, or listen to loud music. But don’t take it out on Laurie, or anyone else. It’s not their fault that your life is shit.
But not all of the criticism has been random abuse from the right. Some on the left have also been happy to line up and fire shots at you too.
Such criticism comes in the ancient and ignobel tradition of the left ritually sacrificing whichever of its own children the right so chooses. Because it is easier to say “oh god, yes, them, they’re shit” than it is to say “no, piss off, I love their writing, and they are my friend”.
And so here is what we have to say:
1) Laurie, you are an excellent journalist. It’s true that you don’t do conventional news journalism in that you are honest about your biases and you write movingly. But that’s great. Why should we expect all journalists to be the same? How boring would that be?
2) Laurie, your writing is wonderfully moving. You have inspired us, and I am sure you have inspired thousands of others. That you write movingly is not something you should be criticised for. Robert Fisk and George Orwell move people. That your prose is sometimes florid is not a criticism either. So was Ernest Hemmingway’s.
3) You are getting shit because you are standing up for what you believe in. We’re all proud of you.
4) You have always been there for us. Whether it was burning the novel in your bag to keep a crowd of us warm and cheerful in the 8th freezing hour of a kettle, or driving round London with Shiv Malik, smoking copiously and trying to track down everyone who had been arrested on the 26th to ensure we were OK; whether it’s arguing our corner on the telly, or standing your ground in the papers, you have been there for us and you have been there with us. When you write about these experiences, and when you write about standing on that line between journalist and activist, you are not selling anyone out. You are saying how it was for you. And we should be grateful.
5) The line between journalism and activism is a complex one, further blurred by the newly emerging traditions of the blogosphere. One of the objections people seem to have is that they think you’ve failed to tread this line carefully enough. This may or may not be true. But, frankly, who cares? Everyone gets stuff wrong sometimes. If we didn’t, we wouldn’t be human.
To people on the left who think that now is an appropriate time to criticise Laurie’s journalism, lay off. There is a discussion to be had about how activists report in the mainstream media on protests that we take part in. There are genuine disagreements about what is or isn’t good writing. But now is not the time. Laurie is our friend. People are treating her like shit because she associates with us. Now is the time to stand together and tell the right that they can fuck right off, that an attack on one of us is an attack on all of us, that Laurie is exceptionally talented and we are lucky to have her in our movement.
Laurie, here’s to you. Know that we think you are great, and that we are grateful for all that you have done.
With hugs,
Bright Green,
Green Wedge
Greenwedge.org
+
Bridget Chapman
Clare Cochrane
(tweet @brightgrn if you want to add your name)
Sad that people resort to attacking those they fear. The bullies need to come in from the cold (can’t be nice out there with poison spewing out of you). Laurie is ‘living in the present’ glad there’s been such a good response to support her. Life is too precious to listen to those consumed by ugly thoughts & feelings.
Hell yeah!
HERE HERE! Well said! <3 We gotcha back Laurie <3
<3 LAURIE PENNY RULZ O.K. <3
My favourite journalist 🙂
Agree, Laurie is an excellent writer, activist and has clearly been a good friend to other activists.
Good luck to her!
On the afternoon of 26 March, Laurie called the Sukey operations room to ask where things were kicking off – not so that she could avoid it but so that she could get directions into the heart of it in order to bring back the real story.
Much later that night, as a few of the team sat on the steps of St Martins in the Fields, attempting to get the truth out about what was really happening in Trafalgar Square, we saw her coming through the lines of riot police as one of the last to escape the kettle.
Laurie is a very courageous journalist as well as being an extremely gifted writer. Sometimes she makes mistakes, we all do; but she is always willing to learn from them. I have nothing but respect and admiration for her.
The abuse directed at her is only proof of how dangerous those who profit from inequality recognise her to be. Her critics on the left would be well advised to look at who they are picking as comrades when put the boot in.
Don’t let the bastards grind you down, Laurie. You are loved and respected by thousands and your career is only just beginning.
Here here!
thank you Laurie, for your passion, honesty and commitment. You have my gratitude for all that you have done and continue to do in the face of this elitist government. My prayers are with you always.
Laurie there are many of us that miss you/your writing. Hope you’re keeping well & it won’t be long before you’re back…. firing on all cylinders! 😉
*Solidarity
Violence and Rape is a terrible thing. She shouldn’t have to fear having a point of view.
hear hear! The tiresome ‘take down’ of any journalist who dares to express views outside of the party line, or the safe middle of the road/middle class world of certain publications is getting old. Laurie Penny speaks for us and thank the fucking powers that be for it!