Has Caroline Lucas just pushed Natalie Bennett out of the London Mayoral race?
Caroline Lucas has just endorsed Sian Berry for Green candidate for London Mayor. Josiah Mortimer discusses the implications for the possibility of Natalie Bennett standing for London Mayor.
The campaign to become the Greens’ mayoral candidate for next May’s election in London is already in full swing. With three candidates already declared – Sian Berry, Caroline Russell and Tom Chance – they’re all canvassing hard for support before the ballots have been sent out to London Green Party’s more than 10,000 members. One candidate, though, just got a massive boost.
Sian Berry – who stood as the Greens’ Mayoral candidate in 2008 – has received a very high profile endorsement: Caroline Lucas.
The extent to which this could affect the campaign cannot be understated – Berry already has a high profile in the Greens having already stood for Mayor, and has most often been in the media in recent weeks over her campaign. She also has a lot of respect and experience as both a Green activist and a well-known transport campaigner.
At the same time, Caroline Lucas is almost certainly the most well-known and admired figure in the Greens – no offense to Natalie Bennett, who has been a tireless and effective organiser at the top of the party. Lucas’ backing for Berry does one very important thing, however – it effectively rules out Bennett from standing.
Firstly, the rumour mill has been going for a long time within the party that Bennett has been planning to stand. It would make sense – she’s the leader of the party, people know who she is, and she has a lot of political experience. It was thought of as a question of when, not if, she’ll declare. This now becomes much less likely.
Caroline’s backing for Berry either says two things: she either knows something we don’t – that Bennett isn’t standing. Or she has pre-empted Bennett standing so that, well, she won’t. For Bennett to stand and not have the backing of the Greens’ only MP would tear the party apart. The press coverage would be an onslaught. The valid talk of a rift would throw the Green Mayoral campaign completely off. And if Bennett won the nomination, but Lucas had backed Berry, this would only be even moreso the case.
Caroline’s declaration for Berry before nominations have closed was quite possibly a tactical move, then. Bennett couldn’t afford to stand without the support of Britain’s only Green MP – the Green campaign would become a fight club instead of a clear issues-based push for a strong Green vote. That, or, as I say, Caroline knows Bennett isn’t going to stand. But all the talk within and without the party is that Natalie is still weighing it up. That decision just became a lot easier.
Caroline Lucas has made clear she is only endorsing Sian Berry for Mayor. Not for the Assembly, any reference to her backing her for that needs to be removed.
I too have been thinking about the London Mayoral race, and about Caroline Lucas’s extraordinary (and most un-Green-Party-like) behavior:
With the likes of Sol Campbell etc getting involved, the Mayoral race already seems to be more about personalities than policies. I guess the Green Party has no choice but to play the game: they need a household-name – a Green Celebrity. Natalie Bennett is a household name, in a way that, with respect to them, the other candidates so far probably aren’t. I agree with others who have said that this is a real opportunity for the Green party and, therefore, they need to show that they’re taking it seriously by risking the leader of the party, and campaigning hard for her (as they did to re-elect Caroline Lucas).
If Natalie Bennett doesn’t run, she is a lame-duck leader. If she runs and doesn’t win, she will have lost the leadership. It’s a hard decision for her.
It seems that Natalie Bennett has ruled herself out of the running: http://www.lbc.co.uk/natalie-bennett-i-wont-run-for-london-mayor-111717
Personally, I think that’s the wrong decision (as the LBC interviewer obviously did too).
“tear the party apart”? – “fight club”? You have a very low opinion of Green Party members.
This whole thing reads like a tabloid gossip column, trying to provoke conflict in the party.
Shame.
Endorsing Sian is a bit of a low move by Caroline.
A post with quotes from Caroline Lucas endorsing Sian Berry as London mayoral candidate has been requested on Green Left Facebook. Nominations of potential Green candidates for the Mayor and London Assembly are not complete and will be subject to an Internal election by London gp members. Bearing in mind that Green Left Facebook is “open to members of all political parties & none” should it carry such endorsements? I would like to ask GL members what they think and discuss this at the agm if necessary.
Personally I dislike the “anointing” of a candidate at this stage especially when we don’t know who else might stand.
Unless you’re entering the mayoral contest targeting 3rd place instead of aiming to win I don’t think it’s compatible with being the party’s leader. Both are full time jobs, you can’t run London and manage the party at the same time.
From the videos I’ve seen of the candidates, Sian Berry seems like the most relatable and the best at making her points clearly. I also think she comes across better than Natalie Bennett. I hope Sian win the nomination!
how many green members would want natalie to stand anyway after that interview. has seriously lost the confidence of all the members i know at least.
However if Natalie stood she possibly could or would not remain leader of the GP & Sian or another would become leader with better communication skills,almost undoubtedly if Caroline had been able to be the leader before the general election, the GP would have got more MP s at the 2015 General election!!!!? Certainly the GP will need a new leader before the next General Election??
Everyone I know is more than happy with Natalie Bennett as leader of the Green Party. Endless sniping about one interview is just silly.